You've Forced My Hand Tay....
On one hand, I'm posting to support you. On the other, to complete bash you. Not personally, but I can't let Beatles bashing go by the wayside... I... just... can't. It is not possible. But first a review...GET UP!
Man, I too was at this concert. It was awesome. As was discussed last night on the drive home, although James Brown sang about 30% of the words he originally did, which wasn't many, he puts on a mean show. The band is awesome, the Ron Jeremy lookalike could play the sax like anyone, and that keith guy on guitar let loose a coupla times worthy of a record deal. That's what good bands do. Backup a singer who isn't as talented as people think, or more appropriately in this case, is one step into his grave. Although his history is dotted with misbehaviour, the man is an artist and performer at heart, and at 70 something, he is as good as always. It was catchy, lively, and full of the funk. What impressed me the most is that he was able to hang around without being propped up for a 2 hour set list. That is crazy long for almost anybody, let alone a guy who simply screams and spins in circles. I also liked him trying his hands at the drums and keyboards. He did quite admirably on drums, and shows he has musical talent on the piano which is nice to see. Jacksoul impressed as well, the singer I've always liked for his voice, but they really were quite good considering their singles and first coupla albumns were so so. As I said to Cara, a true judgement of any band is to here them live. Too bad that idea is falling a bit by the wayside with new age and computer effects. Kinda hard to picture Postal Service live isn't it?
I remember Tay telling that dude to F-off. That was classic. Some little punk and his rock out homies... the metallica comparison is a good one Tay, giving us a hard time for moving into another spot. How dumb was that. Sure, Phil lead us into a tighter spot than we started, but it is one of those things you don't figure out till it happens. But for the guy to get all bent outta shape was ridiculous. Its a dam concert dude. Get over it. I was quite pleased by Tay's response which put him in his place quite quickly. Well done lad!
Tay's Search for the beginning of Punk:
Tay, I agreed in many instances, that the basis that many of the great genres came from African Americans, but I knew you were going to be found wrong on this one. It was just too weird to see how Punk Rock possibly could have come from them. However, I commend your efforts, and actually searching out the facts. I'm simply too lazy to look. As I suspected last night over dinner, the beginning guys would probably be hard to find, Pure Hell it seems in this case. Often with many inventions musical or otherwise, they are sometimes a communal/collective thing and hard to trace to one area or person. People don't think to keep records of things until its important... just like history being written by the conquerors. Just the way things go....
The Beatles and That Uber-Critical Group of Jackasses.
I can respect Tay not liking classic rock. I can also respect your reasoning, although I seem to believe it is a tad flawed. Stifling creativity and progression can be negative. But I would purport that some things deemed "progression" in today's society, isn't necessarily a good thing for humanity. The watered down morals of western society being pawned off as "acceptance" for example. But that's a whole other rant I'd prefer not to do at this time. The point is, sometimes the past can teach us and guide us. I'm not saying we should not listen or promote new music and genres. However, I would not go as far as to say we should promote them and like them for that very reason. Just because its new doesn't mean its good. Its kinda like Natural Selection in a way, if the music sucks, it'll get weeded out. If its good, it'll stick around. As I said in a discussion previously, staying power is a telling story. Not all that matters, but it is a key. The fact that over 3 or 4 generations have enjoyed the likes of elvis, or the beatles and such says something. Something in their music hits a chord with people. I can respect that some people simply don't like that kind of music, but I don't think you can discredit it either. While I think worshipping classic rock or the beatles is a tad too far, I think it is our duty to promote what is good and "classic" for a reason. If we simply stop listening to the Beatles for example, our kids may grow up not knowing what great music is or can be. I understand your point of progression and moving on to something better, but we easily could not get to anything better. Therefore I think it is our duty to uphold what is treasured and good so that it is not lost. This is more a principle of life than anything. If we let go of things worthy of keeping, we let stuff not as cherished fill our time and lives that do not give as much fulfillment. It works on many levels.
My point is, the beatles rock and are a staying influence on music. I don't care what those uber critical jackasses in that artical say. Everyone and everything has their critics, and to put judgement on someone or something off of what their detractors say is not giving them or what they've produced a fair shake. We can all be armchair critics, but their is a greater respect and fulfillment in discovering life and what it has to offer by experiencing it ourselves. Again, this isn't to trash Tay's dislike of classic rock, this is just what I think. I actually don't like lots of rap and I don't like lots of "Classic Rock" just like tay, but my point is to remind everyone that we can disagree and have different likes and interest, but we must respect that very fact.
What's Going On
Finally, after reading this link from Tay, I simply have to tell David Stubbs to shut the hell up. I'm sorry, I know what I said about opinions and interest, but this guy is just a flat out idiot. Man, you can find kinks in anyone's armor, but trying to destroy a legend of R&B and destroy his value after his death just isn't cool. Fine, he used some sappy ass lines talking about Vietnam, but the man used his power and influence through his art to try to make a difference. That's more worthwhile than your damn bickering will ever do. Very classy to point our religion as crutch in his argument. Relgious wars aren't what Marvin was saying when Jesus was the answer. Shows how much this dumbass knows. When people talk about Jesus is key to peace and fulfillness or Allah, or Krishna... the point they are emphasizing is the belief and what they stand for. Love, respect for life, respect for your common man, the balls to do what is right and try to be all that you can be (not to steal a crappy motto). I simply can't stand this argument that critics like this fucker make. I don't know how people like these folk can have fulfilling lives by detracting the worthiness of others. Go fuck yourself David Stubbs...
I said GOOD-DAY!
-CIG
3 Comments:
hmmm, I found this post to be a tad angry. I should remind all that I was in foul mood today, and the beatles thing just was the last straw... upon further review, I do agree with that guy in the article about the strokes... I still love em, but every track is basically the same. but in their case, same = sweet.
Yeah, people still like ACDC too.
Aw man, so jealous! Would love to see James Brown live. His talent is so much more that he basically invented a genre, and a sub-genre within it. But yeah, his band is amazingly talented, we studied them in Rock and Roll class. I'd comment on the punk thing too, cuz we studied that exact topic, but I forget it all now.
Post a Comment
<< Home